Understanding the Case Interview: What to Expect

A consulting case interview is designed to assess your problem-solving skills, analytical thinking, and ability to think on your feet. You'll be presented with a business problem and asked to solve it in real-time. The interviewer isn't just looking for the right answer—they want to see how you approach the problem, structure your thoughts, and communicate your reasoning.

Step 1: Start with the Basics – Get Comfortable with Case Interview Formats

When I first started preparing for case interviews, I had no idea what to expect. I quickly learned that there are common types of cases: market sizing, profitability analysis, mergers & acquisitions, and more. To familiarize yourself, begin by understanding the format and objectives of each type of case. Here’s some common case types:

• Market Sizing: Estimating the size of a market for a product or service.
• Profitability Analysis: Diagnosing why a company’s profits are declining and recommending solutions.
• Business Operations: Improving a business’s internal processes to increase efficiency or reduce costs.
• Mergers & Acquisitions: Assessing the potential success of a merger or acquisition.

I remember my first market-sizing case vividly. I was asked to estimate the number of pizzerias in Milan. At first, it seemed impossible. But breaking down the problem into smaller, manageable parts—like Milan’s population (and the tourists!) and propensity to eat pizza —made it much more approachable.

Step 2: Build a Strong Foundation – Master the Core Skills

Now that you know what to expect, it’s time to develop the core skills required for case interviews.

1. Quantitative Skills:

Consulting cases often involve a fair amount of math. Whether you're calculating profit margins, market shares, or breakeven points, your quantitative skills need to be sharp. Here’s how to get started:

• Practice Mental Math: Set aside time daily to practice basic arithmetic. Apps like Mathway can be handy for this. Trust me, being quick with numbers can significantly boost your confidence.
• Learn Business Math Concepts: Get comfortable with percentages, ratios, and basic financial metrics. I found resources like Khan Academy invaluable for brushing up on these concepts.

2. Structured Thinking:

Structure is everything in a case interview. A systematic approach not only helps you stay organized but also demonstrates your analytical skills. Practice breaking down problems into smaller parts and create frameworks that can guide your analysis.

For example, when tackling a profitability problem, I use the following framework:

• Revenue Streams: Identify and analyze all revenue sources.
• Cost Breakdown: Separate fixed costs from variable costs and analyze each.
• Profitability Drivers: Determine which factors are most affecting profits and consider potential improvements.

3. Communication:

In consulting, how you present your solution is as important as the solution itself. Practice explaining your thought process clearly and concisely. During my preparation, I would often verbalize my reasoning, even when practicing alone. It helped me build the habit of articulating my thoughts, which is crucial during the interview.

Step 3: Practice, Practice, Practice – Simulate Real Interview Conditions

When you're comfortable with the basics, it’s time to dive into practice cases. There are plenty of resources out there, but here’s how to make the most of them:

• Use Online Tools: Modern tools allow you to practice with AI interviewers on websites like CaseWiz. These tools closely simulate the real thing, and allow you to gain expert-quality feedback on how to improve.
• Read Case Books: "Case in Point" by Marc P. Cosentino and "Case Interview Secrets" by Victor Cheng are must-reads. They provide frameworks, examples, and strategies to tackle different types of cases.
• Mock Interviews: Simulate real interview conditions by doing mock interviews with friends or mentors. This was a game-changer for me. Not only did it help me get used to the pressure of thinking on my feet, but it also provided valuable feedback that helped me improve.

Step 4: Review and Reflect – Learn from Every Practice Session

One thing I wish I’d done earlier in my preparation was to review my performance more thoroughly after each practice case. It’s essential to reflect on what went well and where you struggled. This reflection helps you identify patterns in your thinking and areas that need improvement.

After each case, ask yourself:

• Did I structure the problem effectively?
• Was my math accurate and efficient?
• Did I communicate my reasoning clearly?
• What could I have done differently?

Tools like Casewiz provide all this information for you, in easy-to-understand terms. With each interview, Casewiz learns your strengths and weaknesses and provides concrete examples on how you can improve the next time.

Final Thoughts: Start Early and Stay Consistent

Preparing for a consulting case interview isn’t something you can cram for at the last minute. It requires consistent practice and a willingness to learn from your mistakes. The earlier you start, the more time you’ll have to develop your skills and build your confidence.

Remember, the goal isn’t just to ace the interview but to develop a problem-solving mindset that will serve you well in your consulting career. So, start preparing today, stay persistent, and most importantly, enjoy the process. The journey to becoming a consultant is challenging, but it’s also incredibly rewarding. Good luck!

I hope this guide helps you take the first steps toward acing your case interview. If you have any questions or need further advice, feel free to drop a comment below. Happy casing!

‍